A marketing guy at Rocketown Records wrote my first bio. It began:
The first thing you notice about Shaun Groves will probably be his hair. It’s not that it’s particularly wild or strange, but it’s the kind of hair that makes you think, This guy is different, maybe a painter, maybe a musician, but definitely not a furniture salesman.
And in the third paragraph…
Growing up in Tyler, Texas, Groves is a songwriter at heart but has the swagger and look of a rock star (a first for Rocketown!)
I parted ways with Rocketown a few years ago. The label has now shut down. But that bio from eight years ago continues to show up on web sites and in bulletin inserts at churches where I speak and sing. It continues to shape other’s perceptions and expectations of who I am and what I’m all about.
I’m more than a haircut.
I’m not a rock star
I don’t swagger; I’m from Texas and we mosey.
There’s already a perception among many ministers that Christian artists and their music lack any real substance. Cheesy Christian radio morning show hosts and label marketers writing bogus bios don’t help matters.
Speaking of Christian radio morning show hosts, my friend Brant recently wrote an uber-sarcastic post about his perception of Catalyst, based on some marketing language on the conference’s site. The site describes Catalyst as being a gathering of the “doers”, the “cultural architects”, the “influencers”, the “change agents”, the “bold”, the “excellent”, those who are “passionate about something big”, and the “driven” wanting to “reclaim our communities and culture for good.” Brant pointedly pointed out:
It’s just me, based on my understanding of Biblical stories, and how the Kingdom works, but I’d actually be afraid of considering myself a driven, bold, cultural architect, because I think I’d honestly feel like I was disqualifying myself from the work. They’re impressive, sure, but don’t seem the type God chooses, you know, to reclaim our communities and culture for good.
We have an upside-down God for sure, who seems to be biased toward the intimidated (Moses, Thomas, Peter), the unwilling (Moses, Saul, Sarai), the goof-ups (Moses, Abraham, Samson, King David, Mary Magdalene, Rahab), the small (little David, a boy with loaves and fishes, children), the insignificant (fishermen, women, Samaritans, Hebrew slaves). Sure, God loves and uses whoever he wants, but he’s got a track record that’s hard to argue with.
I know several great folks at Catalyst and thankfully one of them – Anne Jackson – showed up to paint a more accurate picture of the conference than the web marketing guys did. In a comment on Brant’s post, she wrote:
Multiple times speakers shared how yes, conferences all over have continued to tell people to be relevant and big and bad and pretty, but they all said how wrong it is, and then challenged us to live out the calling God gave us. That some of us will have “Moses” ministries and that the church isn’t comprised of speakers who get “elevated” to a platform at Catalyst.
She went on to describe, in detail, the many times at Catalyst when the not-famous and not-big and not-highly-influential were championed this year. Then Brant apologized clarified. It was civil, beautiful and enlightening.
What can we learn from all this?
- Marketers create perception.
- We all market ourselves – through blogs, facebook profiles, tweets, resumes, clothing – accurately or inaccurately.
- When marketers lie they make life harder for the “product” and risk turning away “consumers” they may want to attract.
- I am not a rock star who swaggers. Catalyst is better than it’s website says it is. Brant is not an unsubstantive cheesy Christian radio morning show host. Anne is very persuasive.
Pat Callahan says:
“I don’t swagger; I’m from Texas and we mosey.”
That was classic, bro!
Brad Ruggles says:
Yeah, I’ve been on many sites where I’ve almost choked as I was force-fed hype-up marketing jargon. I definitely agree with Anne. Catalyst, as an event and an organization, is a lot more than the marketing rhetoric. I think it’s kind of hard to sum up exactly what it is since everyone takes something different away.
I just know for me that it is the one event every year that helps me keep perspective on just how broad, diverse and powerful the body of Christ is. Sure, some of the speakers hit it out of the park and others hit foul balls but as a whole it has accomplished so much good.
Only someone as creative as you could come into a conversation like this and find the perfect balance between both sides to help remind us to choose our words carefully. Great post Shaun.
Keith Elgin says:
I attended Catalyst for the first time this year. I was very excited about worshiping with 14k people and hearing many speakers I had heard only via podcast, in person. I was excited to get away and focus on the ministry that God has called me to. And I was excited to learn what Christian leadership is about.
Not only was I able to do those things but more than that, I was challenged to always keep the Cross of Christ first. I was challenged to be a worship pastor instead of a worship leader…because, as Aaron Keyes stated, “If you aren’t leading people Monday through Saturday, you’re nothing more than a good singer.” I was inspired by these “great leaders” speakers who were very evidently bowing humbly and pointing to the true Great Leader. I am a witness that the Spirit was alive and well in Atlanta.
Behind all the cool ads, flashy colors, and creativity was Jesus. And somehow at the same time, He was also at the forefront. I guess it could’ve been different things to different people, but to me and everyone I spoke to, it was a call to allow God to lead and us to follow…with Jesus always at the center.
Paul Steinbrueck says:
Shaun, I think most Christian leaders feel this tension between expressing the bigness of the dream God’s given them and the humble realization that ultimately it is only God who can make it happen.
How much of it is our responsibility? How much do we need to learn, plan, motivate, and do to bring about the vision God’s given us? And how much do we rely on God?
Where’s the line between passion and hype?
Marla Taviano says:
Great questions, Paul! I ask myself those same things (a little less eloquently) all the time.
Marla Taviano says:
Great post! And while we’re on the topic, I have a SPLENDID idea for you. Once, just once, could you let someone go on a Compassion Bloggers trip who isn’t a BIG name with a BIG blog with a HUGE following?
Maybe someone who just has a BIG heart for Jesus and a BIG heart for missions and a BIG desire to share that heart through her writing?
Feel free to file this away and get back to me.
p.s. We heart the Caldwell Zoo–have you been?
Shaun Groves says:
Short answer: no
Long answer: Compassion invests money into those blogging trips (hotel, flight, food), which necessitates a return on investment in the form of sponsorships or else we’re being poor stewards and breaking our promise to sponsors that no less than 80% of their sponsorship dollars will go toward meeting the needs of children.
ANY BLOGGER of ANY SIZE can blog about Compassion and link to them as often as they want (compassionbloggers.com for banners and widgets). ANY SPONSOR can go on a “sponsor tour” with Compassion or go visit their child on their own (just let Compassion know a couple months before you plan to be in the country). But unfortunately only a few bloggers have an audience large enough to merit the financial investment. My job though is investing my time and encouragement and mad internet skillz into bloggers of all sizes who wish to use their on-line voice for Compassion.
Need help doing that? Just e-mail me: [email protected]
Marla Taviano says:
I get it. Thanks, Shaun.
Chris Sullivan says:
“When marketers lie they make life harder for the “product” and risk turning away “consumers” they may want to attract.” That hits the nail on the head.
Can we get a picture of your old haircut? Just for kicks. We know you are more than a haircut.
Shaun Groves says:
The image at the top of this post IS my old haircut. It’s the same as the new haircut except dyed black and set off nicely with Backstreet Boys’ facial hair. Classic.
Chris Sullivan says:
I knew I was reading something I thought was relevant to your point. http://blogs.cgdev.org/open_book/2009/10/kiva-is-not-quite-what-it-seems.php Lots of talking going on right now about reality vs marketing materials w. kiva, child sponsorship organizations etc. Would love to hear your take.
Meredith says:
Umm, hi… I’m from Texas too and I would like to aruge that we don’t “mosey.” Mosey-ing implies that we’re slow (interpret that how you will) or even directionally challenged.
I’d like to offer an alternative: we “saunter.”
Webster defines sauntering this way: “to walk with a leisurely gait.”
Clearly, I have too much time on my hands.
Shaun Groves says:
Clearly.
I do, in fact, mosey. I only saunter if I’m in a hurry, like if there’s free TexMex to be had while supplies last.
Kyle Reed says:
First off, Anne Jackson is legit. Love her stuff and more importantly what she represents.
I agree with you on this Shaun. But don’t you think that we, the consumer, have created this mess? We have continued to elevate rock stars to lead us? I know I have. I get caught up in this idea that everything they say is amazing and I sit there and eat it up wanting more, I elevate them to another stratosphere. Ultimately I then elevate myself to that next stratosphere or at least think I have to be there to do something extraordinary. I think that is why the catalyst description is the way it is, you want to be all those things that are described and you truly believe that if you are not you are a nobody, a nothing.
When in reality, God is in the business of using nobodies to do extraordinary things.
I feel so confused as to my response and reaction to all of this, and feel like I am giving into the man by attending catalyst, but I am also blessed to attend catalyst. I got to spend two days with Anne and Carlos backstage and learned a ton from them. I wish I could continue to spend time with them and learn, but in all reality I have to go back to my life and learn from afar, I hate that.
Ok, now I am starting to ramble. Sorry
Great post and call to action. I know what God has placed in my heart and I am working towards that.
Shaun Groves says:
Your no sell-out for attending Catalyst. ONe of my points here is that Catalyst is marketing itself as a conference by and for rock stars and big deals but, in reality, it’s not that at all.
And, yes, we made this monster: Christian fame.
And, no, it’s not all bad. You don’t get to be a rock star without talent. The stars are truly excellent and know some stuff worth listening to. The trick, I think, is remembering that not everyone with talent and wisdom is a rock star. The not-so-big guy/gal often has a lot to contribute to the conversation too. Wish we could hear more from him.
Kyle Reed says:
How do we hear more from him?
It seems like if you do not have a big blogging platform or a book you don’t have much to say.
Does that mean that we are not talented?
Julie Reid says:
Unfortunately the message in the copy is inconsistent with many aspects of the Bible. We are to be the meak, those who affect change through serving the least. It doesn’t say much about what kind of change agents except those who are up to something BIG, what about the widows mite? What about the people who do what they can…..I think the marketing material, is just that material. Unfortunately they say what they believe will tickle peoples need to have that product, to get there, to be in the know….they gotta have that information so they can be an influencer, a better whatever. Its marketing 101.
When they get there what do they do with that platform, that audience….we as Christians obviously are eating up the message because the Catalyst conferences keep growing. The marketing is working……
Terrace Crawford says:
[haha] I remember that bio – when I read over it just when I was booking you for a concert years ago. And you’re right about marketing.
–Terrace Crawford
http://www.terracecrawford.com
http://www.twitter.com/terracecrawford