I remember my first few minutes with Gabriel. I knew in an instant that something was different about him but I couldn’t place it. Then it struck me and shocked me: No ears.
Gabriel was born without ears because a U.S. mining company poisoned his small town by pulling nickel from the ground using outdated (cheaper) methods that are illegal in America. That nickel is turned into batteries for cell phones, toys, laptops and other electronics. Meeting Gabriel left me feeling angry but powerless: What can I do about this? How can I know where my batteries came from and whether or not their production is harming some community somewhere?
On that same trip to the Dominican Republic I spent a morning on a sugar plantation, harvesting cane and speaking with the workers. They all came from Haiti. They were led to believe they were coming across the border to work construction jobs. But when they arrived in the DR, their Haitian citizenship was stripped from them, no new citizenship was granted to them in the DR, and they were put to work for pennies an hour without the freedom to leave the plantation for home or a better opportunity. These men were slaves and I was told that the U.S. company they worked for makes two out of every three cups of sugar purchased in America. Meeting these men left me with more anger and more questions: How can I possibly know where everything I buy comes from and how those who produce it are being treated?
Before the Dominican Republic I had begun to take a stab at frugality. After the Dominican Republic I had a new quest: to balance frugal with fair.
You see, the greatest lesson I learned from Daniel and the sugar harvesters was that a low price for me often comes at a high price for someone else.
Some of the best examples of this come from the clothing industry. That bargain at the mall might have a $10 price tag because the nine year-old who put it together didn’t get paid.
Before the Dominican Republic trip I bought some Hanes underwear and two Mossimo shirts from Target. After the trip I discovered that Hanes has been accused of operating sweatshops in – you guessed it – the Dominican Republic and that Mossimo has been accused of operating sweatshops in Laotia, among other places.
It’s hard to find fair and frugal clothing. It’s even more difficult to find fair, frugal, good-fitting and great-looking clothing. It’s nearly impossible when your legs and arms are freakishly long! But I’ve done it. Among the brands I now buy with a clean conscience, Loomstate is my favorite. I own their jeans, which are usually pricey ($130-190 US), but I got mine on sale for 50% off at thegreenloop.com a while back.
For a limited time Loomstate has a small collection of men’s and women’s clothing available at Target.com and several select Target stores. The dress code for the India trip is dressier than what I have in my closet so I bought Loomstate at Target, confident that no one was poisoned or enslaved in the making of my two new shirts. And – the best part – the prices are less than half of what you’d ordinarily pay for something made by Loomstate.
I’m no economist, but I figure stores stock and companies manufacture what there’s demand for. A lot of people like me are ticked at Target for carrying sweatshop clothing. Now, for a limited time, Target is willing to give Loomstate a little rack space to celebrate Earth Day. I don’t know, but it looks a little like PR; image correction. But what if Target makes a lot of money from its temporary partnership with Loomstate? Could it be extended? What if there’s actual demand for clothes that do no harm? Could more fairly crafted merch hit the shelves of Target stores? I’m hoping.
I’m not suggesting any of us go out and buy stuff we don’t need just to make a statement. And of course secondhand is best. But, if you’re in the market for some new clothes already? Consider Loomstate from Target and let your dollars speak for the Daniels of the world.
What products do you recommend that are both frugal and fair?
Susan Charest says:
that my friend was some good blogging right there.
you have raised the bar for me again – to not live in ignorance.
it always makes me wonder, what else am I missing?
i also wonder if there is a complete book/list of products that are made fairly or rather, that might help a good cause if you purchase them.
most of all our boys clothes are second hand from my nephews but Todd & I usually shop a sale wherever.
i’ll have to ck out the clothes at Target. It would be sort of funny, since the clothing is a limited amount @ Target, if we are start walking around looking like clothing clones.
Texas in Africa says:
As a starving graduate student who cares deeply about social justice, this issue is close to my heart. I just can’t bear to think that the so-called bargain I got at the Gap or Target or whatever came at the expense of a small child’s health and well-being.
One of the things I’ve learned to do is to look for clothing made in Cambodia. Cambodia has strict labor laws that prevent the use of child labor, require safe working conditions, and limit hours for workers to reasonable standards. They also enforce these laws. That pushes up costs a little bit, which makes manufacturers want to move their factories elsewhere (so they can get cheaper labor). I try to buy Cambodian-made clothes whenever I can to encourage the suppliers to keep their stores in the country. Gap/Old Navy carries Cambodian stuff sometimes.
I also don’t shop at Wal-Mart at all. Their prices are very low, and they’re very low for a reason.
Here’s a helpful guide to places to buy sweatshop-free clothing: http://www.sweatfree.org/shoppingguide
heavyd says:
I have to pace myself while reading your blog as you constantly challenge me to change the way I look at the world. Yet another topic that was not even on my radar. Thanks for taking the time…
HeavyD
Suzanne says:
Did you know we use 150 gallons of water when we wash our cars in our driveways? Did anyone know they are rationing water right here in the USA on the west coast? Found this out last night and went nicely with the rain barrels you posted the other day.
I shop almost exclusively at Goodwill for clothing.
Charmaine says:
Loved this blog.
A real eye opener. Thanks for sharing!
Charmaine
Jill Foley says:
I agree with everyone else…another thought provoking post. In my attempts to be frugal, I often buy as cheap as I can. Then every once in a while I wonder if I would be better off spending more for fair trade.
There is a difference between frugal and responsible.
It’s not clothing, but I love Ten Thousand Villages.
http://www.tenthousandvillages.com/home.php
I’ve also been stocking up on some of Compassion’s new shirts – for myself and my kids.
https://store.compassion.com/Customer/index.aspx
Kacie says:
Shaun, I don’t know if this is where you’re going, but if you’re headed to the Bada Kolakate school, that is where my sponsored child is. Her name is Moriyam Gomango, and if you do go there and you do see, her, give her a big hug for me!
stephanie says:
thanks for the heads up on loomstate!
gifts says:
Many wonderful selective information, thanks for partaking. Testament definitely be back more often….