Alrighty, this won’t be short. Let’s recap first.
1. If you need to use the bible to justify gift giving at Christmas time, you’re out of luck: No where are we told to do this. Instead of telling us to give stuff to people to honor Christ’s arrival, it implies that we’re to give ourselves to God.
2. If we changed the way we gave gifts or stopped giving them altogether, we would be more upset and uncomfortable than those we’re giving to. I suspect. You seem to agree. So we can’t really say we do the gift thing entirely for the children. Giving gifts often times/sometimes has a lot more to do with us and our fears, expectations and traditions than anyone else.
3. While the bible doesn’t command us to give gifts to each other at Christmas (it doesn’t even tell us to celebrate Christmas) and while our motives in giving aren’t exactly selfless all the time, there’s nothing inherently evil about this practice of wrapping stuff and giving it to people. Like Halloween, Christmas can be “redeemed” – partly by guarding against the “slippery slope.”
So, as promised, here’s how we handle the whole gift giving thing in our house, in four points with some whys and hows (!!):
Becky and I don’t give each other or our kids a single thing at Christmas.
We don’t give our kids anything because they don’t need, expect or ask for anything. They don’t need anything because they use their own money to buy themselves stuff year round, we buy them small things year round, and they get loads of loot from friends and family on their birthdays – we haven’t put any limits on that…yet. They don’t expect anything because this is all they’ve ever known (soy milk, remember?). They don’t ask for anything because they don’t have cable. Yes, it’s that easy. There’s no built-in need in the human body, mind or spirit for a Webkin or a Wii. The “need” is created. Because there are no need creators in our house (aka advertisers) our kids don’t want stuff very often. And when they do, we get it for their birthday or encourage them to earn the money to buy it themselves. So far, so good.
Santa Clause doesn’t give Becky and I or our kids a single thing.
Well, I’ve written before about how we slayed Santa if you want all the details. Essentially, our kids think the whole Santa thing is something the whole world pretends. Hey, it’s no more of a lie than what you tell your kids. Anyway, seriously, don’t worry: there’s no incentive for our children to tell your children Santa isn’t real because they think everyone already knows that. It’s genius! Complete strangers come up to my kids this time of year and ask them what Santa is bringing. And they
No real Santa means no lists, no waking up at 6AM to get stuff, no two hour present unwrapping sessions, and no worries about whether we’re making too big a deal out of Santa and not a big enough deal out of Jesus. Santa’s a bit player. Jesus is the star.
I think it’s incredible how some people do family worship services or read the Christmas story or unwrap the baby Jesus figurine first thing Christmas morning. Very cool. But we’re not that advanced yet. Simply killing off Saint Nick has been enough to put the spotlight on Jesus at Christmas. In addition though, the last few years we’ve had a birthday party for Jesus, complete with singing and candle blowing and cake eating. My mom’s idea. And a lot of the emphasis on Christ comes from little conversations that just naturally happen. For instance, Gresham, my son, recently asked me if he was going to get any presents for Christmas. He knew he would but this was his way of trying to figure out what they might be. I sarcastically asked him why he would get presents if it’s not his birthday. I asked him whose birthday it was. He said Jesus’ and then I asked him what he was going to give Jesus for his birthday. He thought for a minute and then he said the most profound thing: “Well, Jesus gets…me!” Exactly. And then we talked very briefly about how we could give ourselves to Jesus this Christmas. The kids gave their ideas and we eventually decided to buy animals and water for families in the third world – a gift to poor kids like Jesus. They’re pretty excited about buying a goat.
Grandparents are limited to two gifts per kid.
This is a tough one. And this our first year to man-up and actually ask grandparents to change their ways. As a kid I remember my mom working twelve hour days as the director of a daycare center, then coming home, fixing dinner, and working another four hours sewing stuff that she then sold for Christmas present money. All that work to get me stuff I stopped playing with a few months (or days) later. She didn’t seem to mind. Gifts are my mom’s way of loving people and she’s one of the most generous people I’ve ever known. To give less than a lot to every kid in our family might actually kill her. I’ll let you know. But because my mom loves me she’s agreed to give it a try this year. We’ve assured her our kids don’t expect much for Christmas and haven’t asked for a single thing and will still believe she loves them no matter what. She may be doubtful but se’s playing along. Thanks, mom.
This new grandparent “rule” came about partly because Becky wants our kids to think of their grandparents as people and not toy dispensers and partly because she wants them to do stuff with their grandparents, not just get stuff. So at Christmas, our kids will hunt frogs with Papa, go swimming with Nonnie, do art together or go see a movie. The grandparents are the gift. That, Becky hopes, will be more meaningful to our kids in the long run than a bunch of stuff.
Limiting the number of gifts they get is also good for us. The less we have the more grateful I believe we’re likely to be. The less we have the more responsive we are to those who have nothing. The less we have the less we want. (Odd, but I think true.) Lastly, the less we have the more imaginative and relational it’s necessary we be. My kids spend hours every day pretending with simple things like a box or a ball. Kids don’t need stuff to have fun but when they have a lot of stuff, I think, it can cripple their ability to have fun without it. Visit the third world and see how much fun a stick and a tire can be. Then give a stick and a tire to an American kid and watch them slump, whine, and groan about how bored they are. We’re not doing kids any favors by taking away the need for imagination. So, some stuff, some imagination, and we just hope that works.
I’m no psychologist. I could be completely wrong about every bit of this. All I know about kids is what I’ve seen of my own. Results may vary.
We give gifts
Why wouldn’t we give at Christmas when we give all year round? At Christmas, the gifts change slightly, that’s all. And there’s more conversation probably about why we give, but the giving itself is nothing unique to Christmas. And the stuff we give isn’t all that grand. We give friends food and Christmas cards made by the kids. We give relatives ornaments or frames or planters or some other small thing we make as a family. We give teachers plants and pictures made by the kids. We do the same sorts of things the other eleven months of the year too. When we appreciate someone we give to them – we recognize them. When we hear about a need, we meet it. We work a few hours every week at a food pantry, sponsor kids through Compassion, give to a homeless mission in Nashville, volunteer for this and that, etc etc. The point is that Christmas isn’t a time of increased generosity for our kids or us. There’s virtually no difference in our level of giving from one season to the next – the only difference is the kind of card that comes with the gift.
Your turn. How do you do the whole gift giving thing? Specifically, how do you handle giving your kids gifts?
Amy @ My Friend Amy says:
I don’t have kids, but like your mom, my “love language” is gift giving. So I also actually give gifts year round.
However, there have been years I felt like I went overboard and I’m happy to say that this year wasn’t one of them. This year, I bought books for everyone on my list. Books are the most wonderful gift because there is pretty much a book for everyone and they are incredibly affordable. Plus I was able to use some gift certificates I’ve made from my blog towards the gifts.
I have family members and friends that also do things like bake Christmas presents…which is nice, I’m enjoying some homemade cookies at the moment. But I can’t say I really need them either.
Good post and I’m glad it’s working out for you and your family.
Grovesfan says:
We are trying to make changes as a family too. They’re small, they take time, and they come with some grumbles; but we’re making headway.
We started a tradition with some dear friends about 12 years ago. We would gather at their home after Christmas Eve service and have birthday cake for Jesus. Candles and singing, etc. Sometimes even party hats. Our children would then exchange the gifts they’d gotten for their friends. Our families have always exchanged an ornament.
We haven’t lived near each other since 1999, but we STILL do this each year “with them.” We decide what kind of cake we’ll make and we try to hold it at the same time. We still exchange an ornament each year as well.
Now we invite friends to our house to do the same thing each year. This year, it’s our youngest daughters’ best friend and her family. They just started coming to church with us a few months back. Mary’s friend has been coming to AWANAs with her for about 18 months and is soaking up verses (and their meaning!) left and right.
Last year, instead of having the kids buy for each other, they now just buy for one sibling and it changes from year to year.
Also last year, my kids began choosing a gift for another child their age. THEY deliver those carefully chosen gifts to our local homeless shelter and present it to a child/teen that’s their age. They LOVED doing this!
This year we also decided to dispense with the more expensive gifts for the kids (iPods, cameras, guitars, etc.) and opted for a new computer for the family. Our present one is about 8 or 9 years old (ancient by PC standards) and has been possessed many times by unknown and evil viruses (worse than “Stinky Pete”). I’ve done my best to rebuild it many times, but alas, I think it’s time to lay it to rest. We asked the kids about this and told them that our Christmas budget would not allow for a computer and a “larger” gift for each of them. They agreed that the computer would be a much better way to go as we all get so much use out of it.
As for extended family, we give to a charity in their honor. Compassion, World Vision, Gideons, etc. They name the charity, we give the gift. It’s wonderful and also the one’s receiving the gift certainly benefit; we are definitely the ones that get the joy of giving from it.
These changes are coming over time and they aren’t without hiccups, but we’re trying.
Dawn~Canada says:
Great post Shaun! As for me and my house, we do give gifts at Christmas time. Generally something home made either by our family or by a local artisan/craft sale. Gifts for our three kids are, like yours, limited as we too are trying not to breed consumerism but are trying to teach them responsible spending. We’ve never done the Santa thing, thank goodness, but have taught our kids about the origins of the myth. We too go out of our way to show them how far our money goes in another country thru child sponsorship and goat giving. (Though they wanted to give rabbits?? this year…what do they do with the bunnies, anyway. Supper? Fur hats? Angora sweaters?) I digress. So like you and your family, we do our best to teach our kids to think outside of themselves at the world around them. Not just at Christmas, but throughout the year. We’ve faced some opposition with extended family and get a few strange looks from friends, acquaintances, and strangers about the way we live, but it does spark some good conversation all around. Besides, it would be kind of a pointless existence if were weren’t noticed as freaks on some level, right?
Tamara Cosby says:
Last year is the first year we have done this and we will re-evaluate because of some difference in thinking next year…but here you go:
Our children get a want, a need and a surprise. They are allowed to ask for things but they are limited to receiving 1 of those items. The need can be discussed and this year it is tennis shoes. The surprise varies…and next year things will probably be a lot smaller because we want to establish different thinking in our children and OURSELVES!!!
Robin Storch says:
I’m here via Boomama and although I’ve been by here a few times, it’s been mostly skimming. All that to say, your writing is pretty humorous. Who knew!
Just a thought -slash- possible epiphany I’ve had this Christmas season: If I actually stopped spending all this time and money buying gifts and more time wrapping gifts, I might actually have more time to start some really great traditions with my kids which would allow us, low and behold, to spend time together. Which is really what they inherently want anyway. Right? Ok, I hope so.
Next year’s Christmas Theme: The Gift of Time. Too late this year. I’ve already bought the presents and it would take me too much time to take them back.
Changing this cycle is going to be crazy hard to do.
Morgan Collins says:
well…I guess I need to wait till I have kids to participate in this conversation My family goes overboard…we always have…my mom loves to give presents. so I really struggle with how to approach this season. this year I decided to give things to my family that we can do together. my logic is at least we’re building our relationships and not just adding to the clutter. I still don’t know, though. maybe I’ll have it figured out by the time I do have kids
Kristie Braselton says:
We do a few gifts from us for our kids and a cake and party for Jesus before going to my mom’s house for the onslaught. We’ve also had to limit all relatives to one gift per child or we wouldn’t be able to move in our house. It is truly ridiculous, though I understand it’s because they love the kids. If you try to limit, watch out for the crafty aunt who stuffs several gifts into one ginagantic gift bag. They will try it, I promise.
Last year we gave everyone gifts from gift catalogs like partners international and Food for the Hungry and we asked for a Cambodian well. We got the well through everyone chipping in and everyone loved their pigs and fruit trees and mosquito nets too!
Deidre says:
Shaun, I love this post. Certainly gives us a lot to think about. My husband and I have had an incredible year experiencing God and His timing. Our girls have seen us praise Him for his divine appointments this year. This Christmas means so much more to us as a family and there has been MUCH LESS shopping. I’m sure we could always do a better job than what we are doing, but the focus has certainly changed for us.
PS – Just came from Mt. View Baptist (spoke to you about BooMama – WHAT AN INCREDIBLE NIGHT! Thank you a million times for allowing God to use your life for His glory. I saw HIM when you sang AND I saw HIM when you spoke. My family and I had the best time. Wonderful night of worship!!! Praise His Name!
Kristy says:
I don’t have kids yet, so my gift-giving policy primarily affects me. I do give gifts at Christmas, to my family and a very few close friends. Giving gifts is one of my love languages, but its also the love language of a lot of people in my family, so its important to me that I acknowledge that.
Like others, I’m careful about what I spend. I don’t go overboard, and I’m really picky about the gifts that I give the kids in my life (I choose things that encourage imagination, and actually playing together).
But mostly I just wanted to tell you that I’m fascinated by how you handle the whole Santa issue with your kids. I’m especially impressed that you’ve found a way to teach your kids the truth about Santa, without destroying it for other kids.
Tara says:
Great post!! My parents side hasn’t given gifts for the last 2 years and I gotta say, it was such an eyeopener to see my reaction to no gifts and change (i’m 26! and it was sad to see that I was so selfish and upset I wouldn’t get Christmas gifts! Oh brother! Get over it right?!) SO! God sure has brought me along way and I have a 20 month old son and a 4 month old daughter and I really wanted to start this year not doing the gifts but giving of ourselves. This didn’t go over well with the other side of the family and my husband still want to get the kids a few things. I gotta tell you its super hard for me because I want to raise them right now, like you said, not having all of this so they really won’t know the difference and also so they don’t turn out like me who at 26 was bummed I wasn’t getting gifts! Anyhoo…we too are starting with small steps but THANK YOU so much for posting about this and its so encouraging to hear. I also liked you ideas and the one with 2 gifts from grandparents is a great one. Thanks again and blessings to you this holiday season and all year too!!
Renee says:
Shaun …
Interesting take on the whole Christmas gift thing. For us, we don’t have a lot of money, so we do with very little “fun” throughout the year. Random shopping trips, new clothing, going out to eat … just doesn’t happen for us. Oh, we have marvelous family times of playing games together, etc., but our kids do without most of the gadgets others have. We do not go overboard at Christmas, but it is the one chance we have to give our children some of the “extras.” To watch my daughter worship the Lord along with her IPOD or my other daughter create beautiful original songs on her keyboard … I will treasure those memories forever. My husband works with quite a number of men who annually put-down the whole idea of Christmas gifts, saying if they want or need something throughout the year, they just go out and buy it. Some of us are not so fortunate, so I resent his co-workers spoiling his fun and enjoyment by making him feel “childish” for looking forward to Christmas gifts. We’ll keep giving gifts at Christmas because it brings us joy to bless our children and others. As with most things in this life, the challenge is to find the balance. I think we have.
Kristi Spencer says:
That is so awesome! The Lord has really been tugging at me about this very subject. My kids are 8 and 4 and I did not go “overboard” this year buying them things, but I don’t ever know what to say them when they say thing like why did santa bring my cousin what she wants and he did not bring me what I asked him for. My kids grandparnents spoil them like crazy and they are the childrens ministers at my church and when I bring this up they tell me I am scrooge and and that I am no fun. It is so hard to go the one way when everyone else is going the other. I am going to print off this post you wrote and have them read it because you just said everything that I have been feeling all season. It just makes me feel weird buying all these gifts for them and other people when I KNOW there are people we could really help that won’t even have food to eat on Christmas. I think yall (texas) are right on and I praise you for doing what you are doing.
Lori says:
The idea of asking grandparents to limit gifts is a good one, but it might not work, especially if your kids have cousins and THEY are used to getting lots of gifts (and it’s very possible that the cousins’ parents might also be upset by a reduction if gifts.) How should a grandparent play that situation?
It would be easy to assure a grandparent that they can continue their usual gift giving with the cousins while limiting the gifts to your own children. However, there aren’t many people (grandparents) who have enough stamina to attempt something if they think it might cause conflict, especially if they have an overdeveloped sense of ‘fairness.’ And there are not many people who are willing to take a stand and prepare themselves to gracefully respond to the flack or hurt feelings it might cause.
Fianlly, many people, grandparents included, don’t want to address deeper issues, and would rather keep doing what they have always done for the sake of their own comfort. This is the case with us. My kids have a grandparent who LOVES to give gifts. We tried to talk about toning things down, but the thought of it offends this grandparent. It is, as you mentioned previously, more about themselves and what THEY get out of giving, than it is about what is best for the kids. This same grandparent isn’t real keen on spending fun time with the kids. I think these two things are related… If this grandparent couldn’t give excessive gifts (or any at all,) then they would be forced to show love in some more meaningful ways… and I think that is just too uncomfortable for them. (The sad thing is that this grandparent is a believer.) So, while I like the concept, it all comes down to the grandparents’ willingness to comply… and they may not be willing.
Lori says:
Another thought… one year, my husband and I asked both the believing and non-believing sides of our families if people would donate to a charity or a missions organization in lieu of giving us Christmas gifts.
The nonbelievers HAPPILY complied.
The believers balked at this and were offended. They grudgingly made donations but COULD NOT refrain from buying us something. They got us a crock pot. It felt like a kick in the face, a waste of God’s resources, especially given the fact that WE ALREADY HAD A CROCK POT!
They either couldn’t see how our request was an honest attempt to honor God, or they simply didn’t want to honor him. Either way, it reminded me that, regardless of the strength of my convictions, others don’t always have the same convictions… and I am not able to change their hearts.
Amy says:
There’s also the problem that not all grandparents live close to their grandchildren. My nieces live in Costa Rica and we only get like one Christmas with them every few years.
This year my parents and I went in together and did a 12 days of Christmas theme for them. We bought them small gifts (crayons, notepads, etc.) to open one a day and a biggish gift (a book surprise, surprise) to open on Christmas. We probably won’t do that again because the shipping costs were insane, but it’s a way to remind them that even though we rarely get to see them, we love them and are thinking of them. Similar, I think, to Compassion giving our sponsored children gifts.
Veretax says:
My son Stephen is scared to pieces of St. Nick. We tried to discuss the myth with him early on (I think it was at 2 or 3) and he just freaks out. Come to think about it he’s been a smarty. Holding a 4 Oz bottle on his own at 2 weeks, words at 2 months….now he’s about to turn 6 and is nearly through 1st Grade stuff.
Some checker asked him if Santy was going to come visit him for Christmas and he lectured here LOL. He said in effect, A Big Fat Strange man in a red suit has no business walking around my house at night when I am sleeping! He gave her the Nth degree. I just snickered.
We’ve not gotten him as much this year it seems, or the usual things we typically get like Play dough or colored pencils. (he loves to draw), but With his birthday right around the corner its hard to know how much is too much especially given my mom’s family they tend to go overboard. I might try the gift restriction next year.
My dad’s family though, we quit exchanging gifts a long time ago. We’d give gifts to grandma but we appreciated the time so much more.
I’ll definitely give this more thought next year, thanks Shaun.
FzxGkJssFrk says:
We aren’t giving our kids gifts this Christmas; it’s not as principled a stand as yours, though. For us, it’s because 1) they get more than they need from their grandparents and aunts/uncles, 2) we can’t fit much more stuff in our smallish townhouse and will probably have them donate some stuff to Goodwill, both as a good exercise and as a practical matter, 3) we’ve been on a relatively strict budget, 4) they’re all under 5 and they won’t appreciate it that much anyway.
I’m totally with you on the advertising thing. Our kids watch a little Sesame Street and Mr. Rogers. The only commercial stuff they get is from Thomas trains, which are encouraged (within reason) by their grandparents.
But we never have the “I want thus-and-such for Christmas” in our house, and we don’t do Santa either.
Good thoughts.
Heidi Marshall says:
I think you’re right on as far as what we *should* do. It’s making that a reality which is the hard part. Props to you for making it happen.
Melissa says:
I think you’re my hero. LOL Honestly, this is what I want for my kids, but haven’t had the courage to actually put it into practice yet, although we do keep Christmas to a minimum – about $30 for each of our two kids and there is no Santa. We make cookie trays to hand out; always participate in providing clothes and a toy for a child who needs it from my husband’s school, but I want to do more. I always want the focus to be on giving and not receiving, but it is hard. And mostly it’s hard because of worrying about what other people think (which is ridiculous in itself, but there it is). We also don’t let the kids watch TV so they ask for very little, which is wonderful and as it should be.
Renee says:
You’ve obviously stirred something up, and I’ve enjoyed reading the comments from people on both ends of this thing. I did have a thought … and I want to be careful to not bash my in-laws … They do not give many gifts at Christmas, and we’re fine with that. What they give is useful and practical, no waste. However, they are extremely generous to anyone and everyone else they meet, give lavishly to various charities, etc. I affirm this. We try to do so as well. But my husband (and his sisters, too, for that matter) has grown up with the mindset that everyone else was more important than them. His parents can spend all kinds of time with their friends or church family, but seem to begrudge any time spent with the grandchildren. On the flip side, my parents are very generous at Christmas time. Not overboard, but generous. And, year round, they love spending time with their kids and grandkids. Nothing brings them greater joy then doing a project with the kids or picking raspberries off my dad’s bushes or playing basketball out back. So my kids do not look at Christmas gifts from them as the goal, it’s just another extension of my parents’ love for them, not the main point. Which would I rather have for my kids? There is no question. I see the insecurity in my husband and his sister and I don’t care how generous his parents have been to the “needy:” they have neglected the “needy” in their own family. We’ve been through times of intense financial strain and not once have they ever given us anything or even done so much as ask us how it’s going. How bout a little moral support? But they are quite proud of helping out others who are facing hard times. My heart aches for my husband, a 41 year old man still looking for his parents’ love. Just food for thought …
Geneva says:
Christians giving gifts for Christmas began in a very interesting way. According to my research, those who had enough/ more than enough would give gifts to the poor and to missionaries at Christmas. It was not a gift exchange, as it is today.
ToilingAnt says:
I know I’m late to the party here, but wow. PREACH ON. Especially the part about the grandparents as toy dispensers. The one time I almost flew off the handle this Christmas was on the 26th when my MIL was grilling (a very willing) Girlie about what she wanted for her birthday (today, actually). Granted, MIL *loves* to give gifts, but honestly. The day.after.Christmas. I’m not real sure yet how to change the situation- Granny would be horribly affronted if she was “limited” to fewer gifts- but at least now it’s identified (and I’m thankful to know that I’m not the only one who thinks something’s not quite right).
Jessica says:
Well, I wish we were closer to the way your family does it. But I guess even our weak attempt and not hopping on the consumerism train makes us counter-cultural enough for all of our think we’re weird.
We have 4 children ages 1 1/2 to 9. We give them one gift each on Christmas. We also don’t have cable so they don’t want a whole lot either.
Gifts for family and friends are homemade, usually baked good.
I WISH I knew a way to reign in the other people in the family. The grandparents aren’t really the problem, but we have a few single aunts and uncles who never had a family of their own and they go overboard each year. It’s really terrible.
I have a question for you – Do you set up a Christmas tree at your house? We’ve been seriously considering doing away with the tree. And it’s totally me hanging on to the tradition and not the kids. It’s just so PRETTY. ๐
Jessica says:
Also, could I have proof-read less?
Matthew W says:
Hey Shaun,
I was re-reading this series a few weeks ago, and I was wondering if you could give us an update on how your giftless Christmases are now that time has progressed, the kids are older, and you have more experience with the whole thing. I meant to post this /before/ Christmas… but that didn’t happen, did it? ๐
(incidentally, this series is what brought me to your blog.)
Blessings. ๐
Ann Voskamp says:
I’ve never read this series before.
Yes. Us too. Just. like. this.
Our kids have grown up this way and never known anything different — soy milk.
And yes, too — gifts to community.
Thank you.