Becky was sitting in our front yard on the wooden bench, a tall glass of water in one hand, the garage door open and all it’s toys supplying an endless stream of neighborhood kids, a yard full of happy little people playing all around her.
Ten year-old Jordan from next door wanders over, stands before Becky, looks her in the eye and asks, “Is Santa Claus still alive?”
Without hesitation Becky answered him matter-of-factly, ”No, he died a long time ago.”
“I knew it!”
It was then that Becky realized what she’d just done.
“It’s the parents right?” Jordan continued with his interrogation, realizing he may never again find an adult as ungifted at subterfuge as my wife.
“You’d have to ask your parents,” she said. “I don’t know who brings your presents.”
This is what passes for damage control in Becky’s mind. I don’t know who brings your presents? First carrots and celery were served as snack to kids in our front yard, then they were made to put away their trash and toys before they could head home and now she’s killing their Santa Claus?
Four year-old Gavin from across the street stood at the edge of our garage, half hidden in its shade, his hand frozen over his mouth, his eyes wide and staring at Becky in disbelief. Then he saw something shiny and skipped away.
Shew. That was close.
.
Toby says:
Shaun,
We’ve never done Santa at our house, and this one time, when my oldest was 3, an elderly church member came to the parsonage to see if I would help her hang Christmas lights on her windows. My daughter stood beside me as I answered the door, and Nancy saw her standing there so Nancy asked her, “Are you excited for Santa Claus to come?” to which my 3 year old replied, “Santa isn’t real. He’s just make believe.” Nancy just stood stunned, and then left. We had to have a long talk about not telling other kids Santa isn’t real, he’s just make believe. The moral…don’t put young kids around my oldest @ Christmas time.
Grovesfan says:
We’ve had to have the “don’t spill the beans” talk with our kids too. It can be embarrassing. However, it has caused me to wonder whether perpetuating this lie for other children because “it’s their parents that should tell them, etc.” is really the best thing to do. I know it’s been debated to death, but it still makes me wonder.
Beth
Andy Vandergriff says:
so…that photo has to be one of the greatest things i’ve seen in recent memory.
Nancy Tyler says:
Becky killed Santa Claus by making him eat raw food.
Cristy says:
Sarah Chia says:
Good for her.
We celebrate that there are good people like St. Nicholas, but I hate that his name’s been used as a way to take the focus off of Christ and onto our own selfishness.
keith says:
But did she smell good when she said it? That might just make all the difference.
Shaun Groves says:
If Santa ate raw he’d still be alive and without the jiggling like a bowl full of jelly.
Redneck Neighbor says:
Santa is not real?!?!?
When Gavin is ready for the “talk” I’ll just send him over for that too.
RBerman says:
Great story. Great photo. Our four year old knows that St Nicholas was a Christian who lived a long time ago and helped people in need, and that the Santas he sees around at Christmas are supposed to make us remember to be generous. He knows that Christmas is about Jesus’ birth, but he’s still more excited to think about getting presents. We haven’t given much thought to forbidding him to spill the beans with other kids. Now that he’s in preschool, I guess we’ll have to come up with a plan.
Nancy Tyler says:
Alive, yes. Jolly, no.
Gaetano Buffa says:
Wow. I didn’t know Becky listened to Disciple. (They had the song “Easter Bunny” on their EP “My Daddy can Whip your Daddy” from 1997)
===
Disciple—Easter Bunny—Lyrics
Guess I’m filled with the Christmas spirit
Celebrate a jolly man in red
Hope my kids don’t find out Santa Clause isn’t real
Maybe I should have told them about Jesus instead
Last time I heard about it He didn’t come in a Santa outfit
Santa Clause is dead!
Guess it’s time to thank the easter bunny again
For doing absolutely nothing in my life
What the heck do a bunch of colored eggs
have to do with the Son of God being raised back to life
Last time I heard about it He didn’t rise in an easter outfit
The easter bunny is dead!
Christmas is when I celebrate Jesus’ birth
Easter’s when I celebrate Jesus’ resurrection
Jesus is alive!
=====
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Daddy_Can_Whip_Your_Daddy
http://www.amazon.com/gp/music/wma-pop-up/B000005JAE001005/002-8301464-9931238
P.S. This is the only song clip I could find (in a quick search) on the web where you could hear the lyric “Santa Claus is Dead!”
Shaun Groves says:
Wow. That is a spectacularly awful lyric.
keith says:
I think it’s cool, and who notices how awful the lyric is when you’re screaming it at the top of your lungs?
Thad says:
So, wait….what your telling me is Santa Claus is dead? Bummer…When did that happen?
Scott says:
We haven’t “done” the Santa thing since our oldest son was a few years old. Here’s the problem with Santa, Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy & etc….
O.K. Son or daughter…. Santa, Tooth Fairy, Easter Bunny, and Jesus are all real. Here is some evidence to support this fact: Santa (presents under tree), E.B. (basket with plastic eggs and candy), & T.F. (money under the pillow). No material evidence to prove Jesus….just faith.
Somwhere about age 10….. Remember how we said they were real? Yup…. Well, we lied, except for the stuff about Jesus. Rock on! Jesus loves you. Sorry we lied about that other stuff, but it sure was cute to see you stay up late!
Anyway…. that St. Nicholas stuff is just and excuse to “dance with the fat man in the red suit” and not feel too blasphemous…..
I preached to the youth at our Church that if taking Santa out of Christmas would make Christmas less like Christmas, then you have a problem.