Never ask a woman if she’s pregnant is a good rule to live by. I like this and the other thousands of unwritten unchanging rules that keep the interpersonal peace down here.
But when it comes to race relations, hard rules don’t yet exist. That makes peace hard. So what are we to do?
In A Time To Kill, Samuel L. Jackson’s character Carl Lee Haley tells Matthew Maconahay’s character “the fact is you are just like all the rest of them. When you look at me, you don’t see a man, you see a black man.” And the great sociologists Envogue sang “be color blind, don’t be so shallow” in the early nineties. Pop culture has given us one set of rules but then there’s another according to our adoption classes.
There, we’ve been told that being “color blind” and claiming to see a person and not a person of a certain race is “the worst” thing we could do. To say we see a person’s color but it doesn’t matter to us is also, w’re now told, equally harmful. And to say nothing at all of a person’s race can communicate the same thing without a word.
But maybe…Maybe every race doesn’t have one rule book at all, but is instead made up of myriad individuals – wonderfully unique individuals – with their own set of rules. And we hold to our rules with varying degrees of tenacity. And some of us aren’t aware that we have rules at all. Others are certain they don’t.
If this is true then I’m at once comforted and terrified. Comforted because maybe I won’t break your rules when I break your neighbor’s. Terrified because maybe I will but I won’t know it until I do.
So, at the risk of sounding like John Lennon or Lenny Kravitz, um, maybe the rule of love becomes the most important rule when the other rules aren’t so clear.
Suddenly, instead of being afraid of you, instead of treating you like a set of rules, I’m forced to treat you like a person, to learn about you and what you need from me, to listen, to try and maybe fail and try again. So, Samuel L. Jackson is right…sometimes. But love always is.
MJ says:
I agree: The truth shall set you free. And what do you see? Really see?
Why pretend features, distinctive features don’t exist? They do, and each one is God’s personal masterpiece. Yes, I see a black man, not just a man, or a person in a wheelchair, not just the person. Now, comes the MLK truth, that after the seeing then go on to judge a person by their character and no other distinctive feature….now we can be color blind. And, Jesus said it best “love one another”, simple enough regardless of any feature but knowing each of us is one of God’s perfect creations.
keith says:
I think he was probably also right to get those snakes off that plane!
Kathy says:
Hahahahahahahaaaaaaaaa!
Megan @ Faith Like Mustard says:
Dude, you have got to read “Nurture Shock” by Po Benson. It’s parenting stuff based in neuroscience (but “dumbed down” so us “normal folk” can understand). Other than the chapter on sleep, the chapter on race relations really stuck with me. The gist was that white folk (“folk” must be my word of the day…let’s just roll with it) tell their kids that we are all the same with the good intentions of teaching their kids about equality. BUT, research has shown that it really does a disservice to kids. Basically, we don’t need to be color blind, but show them that God made us differently, beautifully and he loves us all no matter our color (that’s my paraphrase…it wasn’t written from a Christian perspective).
Read it…and don’t skip that chapter on sleep!!! 🙂
Amy D. says:
It disheartens me when people tell their kids or even MY kids that.
Sara @ Happy Brown House says:
We’ve been thinking through race “stuff” alot with our Ethiopian adoption, too. Wondering. Asking the “What if…” questions. It’s tough stuff that starts to swirl around in your head when adopting a child from another race. It makes you question yourself and everyone around you. Oh, it’s tough!
shayne says:
I agree.
I don’t really have anything intelligent to add to this conversation…because really all I’m trying to do is help Jessica with her commentaphobia and get my 2 cents in before she does.
Cause it’s all about loving people ya know? 😛
Amy D. says:
I thought for sure I would already see a comment from her, but she is baking a potato. She’s going to be sad that she wasn’t first.
shayne Welch says:
Ahh yess…the old “baking a potato” excuse.
JessicaB says:
For the record, I again read this before there were ANY comments, but reFUSED to be first. 😛 ! I might have to adopt a next-day-comment policy for now, just to make myself feel better. 🙂
JessicaB says:
And, my potato was fo-real good, y’all. Chili cheese!
Kelli says:
The song “All You Need is Love” is officially stuck in my head. The Moulin Rouge version. Oy…
Seriously, though, another great post. Great food for thought. 🙂
Kyle says:
“…at the risk of sounding like John Lennon or Lenny Kravitz…”
More sentences should begin that way.
Great post.
jen says:
You know, it’s funny, I sit here and wish I could come up with something great to add to this conversation and am sure I cannot. I’m afraid to offend any time race is the topic.
My kids, on the other hand, talk about all of their colors all the time – and the colors of their friends. They compare (to each other and to food) and contrast; they discuss it as easily as discussing the day’s weather. I pray that it is always that way. I pray they always feel that God made them just right.
JessicaB says:
I knew we were back in the deep south (where African-Americans are closer to a majority than a minority) when my Kindergartner came home with this conversation last year:
Five Year Old: I sit at a table with Zoie. She has brown skin but i like her anyway because i love everybody.
Me: Oh, that’s good. Jesus had different colored skin than us, too.
Five Year Old: That’s okay, i love him anyway.
misty says:
Love this!
“Suddenly, instead of being afraid of you, instead of treating you like a set of rules, I’m forced to treat you like a person, to learn about you and what you need from me, to listen, to try and maybe fail and try again. So, Samuel L. Jackson is right…sometimes. But love always is.”
I am a white woman married to a black man. I have 2 beautiful step-daughters who are black. One of my very best friends is Hispanic. Needless to say we have discussions on skin color often. Not daily, but when something happens related to our skin color.
And it happens….often.
Love is always right. Always.
Scott says:
Strange thing…I think we judge people all the time based on our previous experiences with similiar content. Color, like clothing and other external features are often first indicators that we go-to automatically in order to self preserve. We don’t live in a peaceful world (it’s why I visually scan the other passengers when I fly).
I was in Tulsa, OK recently and as I was walking back to my car in a parking garage, I see ahead of me four white guys, mid twenties with heads shaved, tatoos up and down their necks, 501s on and large black combat boots with their jeans tucked in them. My first thought: skinheads or members of a punk band? I’ve got to decide quickly because my life could be in danger if I’m wrong.
Turns out, skinheads. I’m white and obviously of Irish heritage. My colleague that day is obviously of African-American heritage and we both were headed to my car.
Now you tell me, was it wrong for me to begin to judge potential actions based upon race? Because of my life experiences, I know white trash when I see it. I also know black gangbangers too.
So what are we to do? Is it so much about Race or is it about the whole package? My colleague that day is Ivy League educated and was dressed in $1,000 suit. I know he faces first impression biases, but I would bet they are different depending on how he is dressed that day?
alittlebitograce says:
colour is a very interesting thing. i’ve noticed that whites(me) don’t talk about it very much or try very hard to pretend it doesn’t exist. my two closest friends are black and they talk and joke about colour a lot.
my SIL is black and her mother was invited to share christmas with our family. we were having a lovely time, but colour differences were not mentioned. i was chatting with the mother and she commented that we were very nice. i countered with “for white people!” she laughed so hard and loud that she staggered across the room.
at the end of the day, however we approach colour issues, we need to have a lot of love, humility and a good sense of humour.
Brad says:
I am seeing an increasing distinction between generations regarding “color” and “race”. I am 26, and grew up in a town (50,000ish) with about 1/3 white “rednecks”, 1/3 white middle class and 1/3 mexican. Various other ethnicities made up a small fraction of the population.
I’ve found that I’m not naturally prejudiced based on color, but instead by culture. I’ve found myself judging culture based on clothing and speech first… and rarely based on color. I’m naturally more favorable to people who present a first impression of a culture similar to my own, and naturally more suspicious of those who appear to be of a different culture (gangbangers, white trash, whatever…) After I get to know someone it’s a different story, but if there is enough of a barrier built up by the cultural difference I may never give them a chance. (Not saying it’s right, but it’s just what I’ve noticed.)
This seems to contrast with my parents and grandparents generation who pre-judge based off of color first and may exclude themselves from social interaction based on color alone.
I wonder what it will be like for my kids… what will they see first?
Laura Krokos says:
Until college I never wanted to leave the country for fear I wouldn’t know the culture and would offend someone (letting them see the bottom of my foot or something). So true that love cast out fear. If our love for people supercedes our fear of offending thing… well, thats a good thing and can bring life.
Lisa Smith (@stretchmarkmama) says:
One of my favorite reads on the topic of interracial adoption was “Secret Thoughts of an Adoptive Mother.” It doesn’t match your adoption story (nor mine), but it’s a delightful book for those who enjoy hearing the truth in a rather direct (read: sarcastic) way.
(I linked to the book via my name above this comment.)