As part of Skye Jethani‘s blog-based book tour, I got to ask him one question regarding his new release The Divine Commodity: Discovering Faith Beyond Consumer Christianity. Here’s that question followed by his answer.
QUESTION:
Newsweek recently announced that American Christianity is in great peril. The number of self-professed Christians continues to drop along with weekly church attendance while the percentage of Americans with no faith at all is on the rise. Dr. Al Mohler, president of the largest Southern Baptist Seminary, believes these statistics spell the weakening of Christian influence on culture. Dr. Mohler is quoted by Newsweek as saying, “A remarkable culture-shift has taken place around us. The most basic contours of American culture have been radically altered. The so-called Judeo-Christian consensus of the last millennium has given way to a post-modern, post-Christian, post-Western cultural crisis which threatens the very heart of our culture.”
Some fear that Europe, with its empty cathedrals and growing Muslim population, is the crystal ball in which we may see America’s spiritual future most clearly. These days we American Christians are routinely told that church pews are emptying, people of all ages are abandoning institutional church and the Christian faith. Yet it’s at this time that you choose to write a book which I think questions the validity of all this measuring and worry.
What message does God have through The Divine Commodity for church leaders and the rest of us who are fretting over the dwindling size and influence of the American church?
ANSWER:
I believe the North American church is in a time of “creative dislocation.” I agree with Dr. Mohler that we are seeing a remarkable cultural-shift, and that the “Judeo-Christian consensus of the last millennium has given way to a post-modern, post-Christian, post-Western” culture. Where I depart from Dr. Mohler is when he calls this a “cultural crisis which threatens the very heart of our culture.”
Christianity is indeed losing its privileged position of cultural authority in North America, but this dislocation is creating the conditions for God to do something new within and through his people. For those who believe the church and its mission can only succeed by maintaining control of schools, institutions, and governments, then I can understand why trends outlined in the Newsweek article would stir worry. But my guess is that these folks have bought into what I call The Daisy Cutter Doctrine (as discussed in Chapter 9 of The Divine Commodity).
The Daisy Cutter Doctrine is the belief that God’s huge mission can only be legitimately accomplished with huge methods. For example, to impact the United States for Christ, Christians should seek control of the United States Government. Or, if we want to shift cultural values Christians should be producing Hollywood blockbusters that promote the virtue of monogamous, heterosexual marriage. The idea is that a big mission requires big methods for a big impact.
But with Christianity and the Church becoming increasingly marginalized in our culture, the opportunities for massive cultural impact are shrinking. This, I suspect, is what has people like Dr. Mohler so concerned.
I am not.
The overwhelming witness of Scripture is that God transforms the world using the smallest and most unlikely methods—the outcasts, the underdogs, the forgotten, and the under-resourced. Last week was Passover and Easter. In one story the most powerful empire on earth is defeated and plundered by a band of poor slaves in communion with God. In the other story, the powers of evil and hell are defeated by the death and resurrection of a poor itinerant preacher from the backwaters of Galilee.
Beyond the testimony of Scripture, a glimpse at the state of global Christianity shows that many of the places where the faith is growing most rapidly are also where it lacks a privileged position. China may be the most vivid example, or among the Dalit (Untouchables) of India.
For those church leaders that have great concern over the “decline” of Christianity in America, I believe The Divine Commodity carries a message of enduring hope. God may be simply refining his church and burning away the cultural dross that we’ve acquired from our privileged position. This refining may be painful as we lose institutions, facilities, and even some previously impactful ministries. But in the end I have great confidence that Christ’s Church, even in America, will prevail. For when we are weak, then we are strong.
~Skye Jethani
————————————–
To visit the other blogs participating in this book tour, go here: http://zonderfann.com/2009/04/14/blog-tour-for-the-divine-commodity
To purchase The Divine Commodity (I highly recommend it), head over to Amazon.com
Cheryl says:
Great post and interview, I’m really diggin this author! Take a look at another perspective from an influential church leader, Greg Boyd – http://www.gregboyd.org/blog/dont-weep-for-the-demise-of-american-christianity.
The first part of Greg’s post is kind of intellectual, but hang in there because Greg gives his perspective toward the middle of why the demise of American Christianity is actually good news.
The premise? It’s summed up well by Alan Hirsch in the book The Forgotten Ways “The Kingdom has always thrived — and really, has only thrived — when it was on the margins of society.”
Chris says:
Okay, you got me. I’m intrigued. I’m going to buy the book. I think on some level I’ve always felt like Christianity thrives on the margins and compromises in power. Here is to being “subversive”. Can’t wait to read the book.
Sarah says:
I’m so thankful for Skye’s perspective on this. How refreshing to hear words that are so *gasp* biblical!!
CardsFan says:
Based on what I’m reading, this book sounds like checking out. I’m not ready to buy into the idea that eliminating Christian influence in all areas of life (politics, business, education, etc.) is good for Christians or people in general. Much civil good has been conducted by Christians boldly living what they believe in the public square. Having said that, I certainly agree that the Bible bears witness to each individual’s responsibility to carry the gospel in a personal manner and the effectiveness of persecution in spreading the gospel. If we look to broad-brushed institutionalization of Biblical mores as the mechanism to maintain Christian living, then we fail God’s calling.
Krissy says:
Greg Boyd has a post on his blog that talks about this issue in a similar light: http://www.gregboyd.org/blog/dont-weep-for-the-demise-of-american-christianity/
Shaun Groves says:
CardsFan, not at all. This book is not about “checking out.” You’re way off in your understanding of the book – no fault of your own. You just need to read the sucker.
Cheryl says:
To Chris: I’m with ya . . . right after I finish Greg Boyd’s new book “Myth of a Christian Religions”! From the back cover: “The kingdom of God is a beautiful revolution. Marked by the radical life, love, servanthood, and humility of Jesus, it stands in stark contrast to the values and ways of the world.”
Brooke says:
What a relief to hear this spoken out loud. Having researched the persecuted church for years and having ministered to it directly … I am so thankful to hear this correct perspective. God uses Daniels … but we tend to discount that simple, daily, unseen-by-millions, where-the-rubber-meets-the-road obedience … living out our lives right where we are. That makes a far greater impact in so many ways. The gospel spreads in these ways. God is bigger than media and laws of all kinds … not that He doesn’t use them. But American Christianity seems to place its hope in the founding documents, instead of the Bible.
MamasBoy says:
There is a tremendous competition for influencing the culture between pagan/agnostic beliefs and Christian beliefs. Christian individuals and institutions are currently at risk of losing the right to abide by Christ’s teachings when helping society through social programs and work. Should pharmacists be forced to provide potential abortifacients like the morning after pill or lose their job? Should Christian hospitals and adoption agencies be shut down for refusing to capititulate to the culture at large in providing abortion and gay adoptions? Many people of political prominence would say yes to those questions. One of the reasons that Crisis Pregnancy Centers have been so effective in their work, is that they have been able to fight off crippling government regulation through the cultural and political influence of their religious backers.
Another large concern, is how to pass on the faith when the educational establishment is antagonistic to Christianity and has a huge influence on one’s children for 13 years of their life before they move out.
If Christian social justice and charity work can simply move more toward individual one-on-one action, and if parents can continue to pass on the faith to their children when society is antagonistic to the faith and tremendously intrusive/influential in children’s lives, then maybe the loss of Christian institutions and influence would be a blessing in disguise. However, those a very big ifs. Increased marginalization of Christians does not always result in increased vitality for Christianity. After all, Turkey was once a Christian country.
Then again, it could be the case that Skye Jethani is correct and Dr. Mohler is wrong. After all, it’s pretty obvious that the Church could use some pruning. I’m not a prophet, just a skeptic.
MB
CardsFan says:
Shaun,
Poor choice of words on my part. I meant that the book is worth reading (checking it out!!). It is definitely on my reading list. Thanks!!