I’ve always ignored those people: The ones who get very upset at Target this time of year and decide to e-mail me and the rest of their address book about it. This year, to those people, I would now like to preemptively say Simmer down. And also…
There was a time in American history when Christians could be counted on to get angry about the right stuff – the stuff that seems to have made Jesus angry. In the 1920s, for instance, when Saint Nick became the patron saint of American consumerism, most Christians in this country opposed the holiday because of its inextricable connection to materialism and self-indulgence.
In 1931, the New York Times surveyed Christmas sermons and found that they held to one main theme: “the suggestion that Christmas could not survive if Christ were thrust into the background by materialism.” One sermon called the days leading up to Christmas, commonly called “Advent” by Christians, nothing but a “profit-seeking period.”
Fast forward to 2005. The American Family Association spearheaded a boycott of Target because the retailer wished shoppers a “Happy Holiday” instead of a “Merry Christmas.” The AFA wanted to make sure all our self-indulgence and materialism was being carried out in Jesus’ name.
Bizarre.
Skye Jethani, in his book The Divine Commodity, points out the nuttiness and inconsistency of those people better than I can:
In less than a century, Christians have gone from opposing over-consumption at Christmas to demanding it be done in Christ’s name alone. The explanation may be in the numbers. Two thirds of the U.S. economy is based on consumer spending, and 50-75 percent of most retailers’ annual profits are generated during December. This makes the weeks before Christmas the high holy days of consumerism. If Christians engaged in the Advent season as they did in generations past, by modeling moderation and self-denial or by ignoring the holiday altogether, it would likely destroy the economy. To ensure economic survival, consumers are stirred into a buying frenzy every winter with the goal of making this year’s shopping season more prosperous than the last. Santa Claus has been the mascot of this manipulation since the early twentieth century, but if more Christians have their way the season of shopping will someday be inaugurated by the appearance of Jesus Christ at the end of the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade.
Feel free to copy and paste this post as a reply to the angry e-mails you’re sure to receive this month. My gift to you. Merry Christmas.
a thorn among roses says:
true and powerful words…and great reminders. booo yah!
Ally Simpson says:
amen
Mandy says:
Love this.
Jason says:
Right on.
Danny says:
I can tell already that I’m going to be using this gift quite often…
Krissy says:
This is a great gift. Thank you!
Texas in Africa says:
Amen and amen.
Mark Hollingsworth says:
Agree whole-heartedly, Shaun!
misty says:
Thanks…great post as always!
ben power says:
Thanks for the gift, Shaun.
thomas says:
Darn it, I so badly want to be one of those people. I want to continue to fuel my anger at everyone and everything by acting self righteous and demand that everyone do the same. In fact, I think it is time to boycott the people and organizations that do not boycott Target.
BOYCOTT!! BOYCOTT!! BOYCOTT!!!
Thomas
Zach Nielsen (Vitamin Z) says:
My thoughts…
Why are we expecting non-believers to ascribe to something that means nothing to them? Does this help us promote the true meaning of Christmas? Why would we expect any different? I don’t get it.
Whether unbelievers use the words Happy Holidays or Christmas is of little consequence as to their understanding of the Gospel. In my view, this kind of stuff only hurts our mission to communicate the truth of the Gospel. If you think people using the word Christmas somehow makes our materialistic holiday extravaganza more pure you are probably not paying attention very well. Boycotting secular businesses that do not exhibit the kind of behavior that we think they should is the last thing that an unbelieving world needs to see.
The main question this website asks is, “How Christmas Friendly Are Retailers?” What does retail have to do with the essence of Christmas anyway? Obviously, the true meaning of Christmas is very important to us and we want to teach our kids the meaning of Christmas, but that is not going to be found in any retail store, no matter how “Christmas friendly” they are.
Let’s say that the CEO of Best Buy somehow stumbles upon this website and he happens to be a hard-core Christian skeptic. Do you think that this kind of a website is a helpful Christian witness for him? I doubt it. It serves the opposite goal. If we want people to cherish Christmas the path to seeing that accomplished is not paved with boycotts and angry comment sections on a public website.
Do we expect our unbelieving Muslim friends to acknowledge Christmas? Do we expect our unbelieving Hindu friends to acknowledge Christmas? Do we have unbelieving friends? Isn’t this just a subtle (or not so subtle ) form of legalism?
http://takeyourvitaminz.blogspot.com/2009/11/christmas-business-boycott-no-thanks.html
JLI says:
You just MADE MY DAY, Shaun.
I was listening to Delilah on the radio last week and one caller described her family’s tradition of giving OF themselves by giving TO others; each year they think of something they can offer of themselves that will be a blessing to others instead of buying gifts for each other.
This message is HUGE and speaks perfectly for my feelings on the matter.
Thank you so much. I pray this reaches far and wide!
Rebecca says:
I agree.
We even have a school here in Oregon who cannot have any symbols of Christmas because it is symbolic of religion, and that makes some adults uncomfortable. I am sorry, but suck it up. It is a religious observance. I think that we have become such a politically correct nation we wouldn’t know the truth if it slapped us in our collective faces.
My husband and I are giving thanks this year for the real reason for this season.
Princess Leia says:
Our small group is reading through this book right now and really being challenged to see/speak/think differently.
Not at all as an indictment of our church leadership, but simply because we _have_ been so challenged by the book and want others to know why we’re acting so strangely, we’ve also decided to give several of our pastors and leaders a copy of the book for Christmas.
I think Mr. Jethani would appreciate the irony of us buying multiple copies of his book, thereby supporting our consumer economy, in order to encourage our church leadership to eschew the consumeristic bent that we’ve been tip-toeing toward.
Lori Jo says:
thank you for saying what i feel. and putting a heck of a lot of information that i didn’t know to make it sound better than i could’ve done…:]
Adam says:
so.. basically to piggy back on to everyone else.. Your awesome Shaun.. and your post is awesome too.. ahahah..
no but seriouly that was a great post. I did find the FOF site that rates how Christmas friendly companies are. Some of the comments made me so angry with what they would ask and how they would behave. I mean here we are supposed to be an example of Christ…and i am sure it would only make the people working at the store be like…what the heck?!?!? I am all about living my life as a example of God’s love and his word.
Amy @ My Friend Amy says:
That’s interesting. I knew that the idea of “keeping Christ in Christmas” wasn’t a new one, and was an old battle, I just didn’t realize it used to be framed in that way.
I do buy Christmas gifts, but this year I’ve scaled way back.
Kelly @ Love Well says:
I’ve had a post similar to this percolating in my brain since last Christmas. There’s really a huge difference between Jesus coming and the American machine called Christmas. I wonder why we, as the church, work so hard to enmesh the two.
Shannon says:
Yes, yes, yes.
E-Jayjo says:
I’ve never thought about it that way, but you’re absolutely right. If we force Jesus as the reason for the holiday and boo-hoo about Santa, but all the while we are out elbowing our way through black Friday sales, then we are saying that our greed and consumerism is because of/for/in honor of Jesus.
misty says:
Kelly @ Love Well says:
December 7, 2009 at 11:07 pm
I’ve had a post similar to this percolating in my brain since last Christmas. There’s really a huge difference between Jesus coming and the American machine called Christmas. I wonder why we, as the church, work so hard to enmesh the two.
Completely agree!
Amber says:
Encourage generosity.
Spend more this Christmas.
http://bit.ly/aO9ms
(no, it’s not as quackish as it sounds, and I’m not selling anything)
Veretax says:
I’ll admit I’m recovering from getting upset about that sort of thing. It used to get on my nerves greatly. This year however, I came to a very important realiziation. Maybe its because for the first time I’ve been working to read through the bible in a year, I don’t know, but my opinion of it has changed.
For one thing I have to wonder about the ignorance of the ACLU and PC crowd that prefer the words Happy Holidays to Merry Christmas. You see, I was reminded this year that the word Holiday used to be considered a compound word. What do I mean by that? Well think about it. Holi-day, Holy Day, where does this come from, well I don’t know the exact origin, but this phrase is used in the Old Testament frequently to refer to the festivals and feasts the Israelites were instructed to participate.
That may sound like nothing knew, but the realiziation that came to me, is that these people, are unknowingly wishing that we have an enjoyable Holy Day. I can’t think of a more religious substitute for saying Merry Christmas. Let’s be honest, if they REALLY knew what the word Holiday meant, and where it came from, do you think they would keep saying it?
I do not think they would. I think they say it in ignorance, and under pressure from the PC crowd. Well, I do not let it bother me anymore, because if these people feel the need to wish me a happy time in a festival or feast to the Lord, even if they do so in Ignorance, why should it matter to me?
I don’t know why this never occurred to me before, but its totally changed my outlook on this issue. Thanks for the blog Shaun, you made some very, great points, and I agree, Christmas is very Material for most Americans, it is rather sad.
James Kevin Burkhardt says:
December 25 is not Jesus’ true birthday. The calendar of Christian events was turned around by an evil emperor to satisfy the masses who didn’t want to give up their pagan celebrations and there’s been confusion ever since. (Gee — who is the author of (confusion?) Hmmm. So culturally now we have a Santa Claus, an Easter Bunny and Halloween which overshadow the Feast of Tabernacles, Atonement and Passover – those are God’s Holy Days from which we get the word holidays. Even Christmas is a compound of Christ and Mass.
Alexis says:
I never thought of it this way Shaun.
I stopped shopping at Target when they stopped allowing the Salvation Army to ring the bell. Haven’t been in since, year round.
I liked someone else’s reply about holiday=Holy day. So anyone who is upset, when someone says happy holidays, they can reply “Happy Holy day to you too!” No reason for anyone to be upset, right? 😉
Carole Turner says:
We live in stinkin Sodom and Gomorah! It’s hard to resit, very hard. We buy three gifts for the kids and that’s it. I even give recycled gifts to teachers.
My daughter just started earning money babysitting and she has been buying gifts like crazy. I think for her it’s still innocent. But I need to talk to her about doing something lasting with that money.
Sally says:
excellent post!
Wayne says:
Hmmm? I should start by saying I live next door, to the north. American culture both fascinates me and makes me puke. It seems like American Christianity has morphed into some kind of self righteous monster (Please excuse the broad brush of my comments). I realize that there are many shades of Christian but the two noisy extremes, the righteous right and the prosperous left, seem to have forgotten the humble Jesus. I think they should all just shut up and love their neighbours.
So, Merry Christmas everyone, and SHUT UP!!
Pat says:
I love it!
TC says:
Well said, Shaun.
I would also like to add a reply to “those” who fight for “the real meaning of Christmas.” We are not really sure when Jesus was born; perhaps in the spring when shepherds were watching after the many newborn sheep (Luke 2:8). Christians began celebrating Jesus on Dec. 25, which was the date of the Roman holiday Saturnalia.
With December becoming so overtly commercialized – even non-Christians realize that, and are craving for more – we have great opportunities to set the record straight and put to rest so many silly misconceptions about Jesus, from inside and outside the church.
Blessings.
Andy Holt says:
Shaun, I think you’re right. My solution to this problem would be for christians to pull out of christmas altogether. Declare say September the whatever as Jesus’ birthday, get some numerate theologian to work it out and hold our own celebration of God taking on materiality (is that a word?) People are so fed up of being ripped off at Christmas that they’d join the real thing in droves.Christmas is bad news for the poor, the lonely, the addicted and the already-under-pressured ones and that doesn’t leave many suckers for the stores to fleece, Happy Christmas, one and all!
Charissa says:
I just read this because one of my Facebook friends linked it to his status.
I think that you have a point about the pettiness of Christians getting all freaked-out about “Happy Holidays,” especially with “Christmas” being over-commercialized.
However, I think even the “overcommercialization of Christmas” and cracking on Santa is kind of stale too.
I would like to share a story: I work on a military base, and we had a party for military families where they could take their kids to see Santa and ride a few carnival-type things. I volunteered to be one of “Santa’s Helpers” at this event; while helping, the ‘Santa’ asked me to get the names of children before they came in to see him so that the child would feel that Santa knew their name. One child in particular, when Santa called his name, positively lit up, and I could tell that he felt, at that moment, like the most special boy in the world. I think that is a great picture of who Jesus is- a famous, important, well-loved person who gives generously to the whole world, and he remembers YOUR name, and welcomes you to his lap, and makes you feel like you are special. I knew it was a God-moment when I saw it because I had seen about 300 people prior all day, and felt pretty cynical until I saw that boy- I almost cried when I watched this.
Andy says:
I am with you Charissa, coming here via friends facebook link, and just scratch my head not only at the stale take on Santa and consumerism – I mean I’ve been hearing that since ’93 – but just as worrisome is the self-righteousness of the poster. Really? “Those people'”? Are “those people” ones for whom Christ died? The general trend of “cool evangelicals” is to define themselves by the culture and against other Christians. It earns the applause of their unregenerate friends & makes them think they are just like Jesus.
Lourens says:
Why don’t we just start a new tradition on Christmas day. Instead of giving presents to one another we go out and help someone in need, maybe even give them a meal to enjoy. Or better yet, make a community outreach event where we hold a meal for the poor and destitute. I suspect Jesus would endorse this.
Amy D. says:
I love this tradition! My daughter gave up her birthday this year, and she is giving up Christmas presents as well to donate to Gifts of Compassion. 😀
dean says:
Lourens
many believers in many communities are doing just that… fantastic idea! i was at my in-laws’ for Christmas and the closest such ministry i could find was several hours away, and they were delivering most of the meals. i wasn’t sure how much use i’d be trying to deliver meals in a community i didn’t even know how to get TO, much less get AROUND… anyway, as it turned out i woke up Christmas morning sick as a dog and ended up never leaving the house. we have decided that next Christmas, we’re going to give to Compassion and several other ministries in the names of the folks we’ve bought gifts for in years past, and are encouraging them to do the same instead of giving gifts to us. that was actually the plan for this year, but we failed to get the word out in time, but starting next year, that’s how it’s going down…
Lon Lickluck says:
Shouldn’t any book titled “The Divine Commodity” at least be available as a free download?
sharon gill says:
Looking for a good site to uplaod my hard house mix to any ideas i would need some feed back on my mixing as i am new to the dj world thanks
Yeni Diziler says:
Thank you very much for your geat post…
Maureen says:
Me and my friend were arguing about an issue similar to this! Now I know that I was right. lol! Thanks for the information you post. My blog http://www.supplyjewelry.com/jewelryfashiontalk/