Wow.  Cheer on the compassion and hard work of a church in the third world and a lot of folks say “Amen.” Talk a little smack about a big plastic whale and quite a crowd gathers to leave their two cents.

95 people left comments on a recent post of mine called Our Witness about a pastor in Kolkata, India whose church is caring for hundreds of children in its neighborhood because, he said, “Our witness is our service.” 95 attaboys for this Indian congregation or stones thrown at our allegedly more self-absorbed churches in the West.

One of those comments stood out to me more than the others. I kept coming back to it for hours after I first read it.  Jared Wilson, a complete stranger but apparently a pastor here in Nashville, said in part, ”…the Bravo’s ring hollow to me. Put up or shut up, is what I say.

Ouch.

Like I said, I don’t know Jared.  I don’t know everything that’s behind those words but I wondered if he was a tad irritated, if he’s pastored Christians more apt to criticize shabby work and cheer excellence than roll up their own sleeves.  “Put up or shut up,” he said.  So I did something to prove that the comments on that post weren’t just hollow words and well wishes.  No, I thought, if they’re simply asked I bet most of these commenters are ready to get to work meeting the needs of their neighbors themselves, if they’re not hard at it already.  They’ll put up.

So I posted the My Witness Challenge.  I spread the word about it through Twitter and Facebook – rallied all the troops I could. I asked everyone to dream a little and share their plan for meeting the physical and spiritual needs of those around them.  I asked everyone to write down their plan and send me the details or a link if they blogged them.  I promised I’d compile everyone’s great ideas and post them here today so we could all be inspired and bring some more of that good work we all loved in India back home where we live.

*crickets*

Are we all talk?

Then, a trickle.  A tweet here.  An e-mail there.

-Stretch Mark Mama posted 10 Marginally Interesting Ideas

-Matt Cleaver posted quite a few of his own.

-Lindsay posted some things we can and could do.

-So did Happy Geek.

-Misty wrote about what she’s already doing to serve female prisoners.

-Molly wrote about her work in Belize.

-Cheri wrote about what she’s doing with the Haitian community.

-And several people just left their ideas in the comments of the My Witness Challenge post.

And there may be more out there.  If I missed yours, let me know and I’ll add it to this post.

This is a great start! This is plenty to get us all inspired and thinking a little more clearly about how we can each serve our communities like that little church in India did.

But, at the risk of sounding ungrateful or discouraging, I’m a little disappointed really.  95 people applauded one church’s great work and booed American Christianity in general but only a handful of people were enthusiastic or disgusted enough to do more than leave a comment? 

And, you know, I’m being hard on us, really.  Unfair.  I know. I know. We’re busy people.  We have jobs and families and soccer practices and whatnot.  There’s not a lot of time left for homework like this. And some of us just need more time to ponder before we go off dreaming up some big plan and writing it down for all the world to read.  I get all that.  But still, I just wish there were as many people contributing as there are criticizing and cheering the contributions of others.

It’s not too late to share your ideas.  We’re listening.